02-02-2004, 05:06 PM
Not all porn is like that! I mean, even some of the lemons here last hundreds of pages, have a long, carefully constructed plot and are quite deep for what they are. I think there are two kinds of porn:
1. whack-off material - doesn't need plot or logic, only the sex matters
2. art - sex scenes built around the plot and not vice versa, great attention to detail, created not so much for the purpose of whacking off but for general enjoyment.
Now, this dojin tried to be in the first category -- and it succeeded. It's not as if it'd tried to be in the second one and had failed. It did all it set out to do, so I don't really see anything to be criticised there. If you just don't happen to like the first category, then that's a matter of taste and nothing to criticise the artist about.
Oh, and @ Waru: That dojin you're describing there sounds kinda fun, is it one of the ones at the DHZ? 'cause if it is, I might just skip over there and grab a copy ;)
1. whack-off material - doesn't need plot or logic, only the sex matters
2. art - sex scenes built around the plot and not vice versa, great attention to detail, created not so much for the purpose of whacking off but for general enjoyment.
Now, this dojin tried to be in the first category -- and it succeeded. It's not as if it'd tried to be in the second one and had failed. It did all it set out to do, so I don't really see anything to be criticised there. If you just don't happen to like the first category, then that's a matter of taste and nothing to criticise the artist about.
Oh, and @ Waru: That dojin you're describing there sounds kinda fun, is it one of the ones at the DHZ? 'cause if it is, I might just skip over there and grab a copy ;)